The Difference Between a Water Garden and a Koi Pond

Before ever starting on a pond there is one question you must ask yourself – "Do I want to ever have fish in my pond?". There is a big difference in the way a water garden and a fish pond are built. Fish need filtration (and an adequate amount of it!) while a garden pond, depending on how clear you want your water, can have nothing other than the plants themselves. Also, more maintenance is needed for a pond if you have goldfish or koi.

Water Gardens

Dig a hole, put in a liner, decorate the edges and hide the liner. Put in a pump to circulate the water, if you so desire, and add a waterfall or decorative fountain. Add plants. Bingo – you now have a water garden!

Water Gardens are quite easy and, if murky water does not bother you, there is no need to add filtration. Plants are nature’s way of filtering water and, in some cases, the abundance of plants will do quite nicely to keep your pond clear except for Algae Bloom.. Algae is also very natural.

Fish Pond

Fish are dependent on the pond as their home and must have proper filtration and aeration to remain healthy. Therefore, there are many precautions that you must take when building a pond that will one day hold fish. For instance:

Dig Your Hole – Many people like to include a plant shelf around the edge in a Water Garden to be used for plants and safety reasons (if a child falls in he may only fall onto the shelf). Though this is decorative and useful, it can be used by a predator, such as raccoons, for a fishing hole or to stand on while catching the fish. Our advice is to leave out the plant shelf if it doesn't create a health hazard.

Put in a Liner and Decorate the Edges – No difference really except watch what edges jut out onto the water’s edge. Fish, especially during spawning, will jump up from the water. A jagged edge of a rock could be lethal.

Put in a Pump to Circulate the Water – Not just any pump will do for a pond that contains fish. We recommend turning the water at least 1 time an hour so if you have a pond with 700 gallons, you should have a pump that will circulate 700 gallons per hour.

Add a Waterfall or Decorative Fountain – You must create bubbles for fish to breath. (Yes, they need oxygen!) A simple return of the water through a pipe may not be enough or you may need to increase your bubbles at certain times. Critical times of needing increased aeration are (1) at night, (2) whenever you add chemicals or medication to the water, (3) whenever you add salt and (4) during outside temperatures of high 80's or low 90's and above. By placing a fountain, air stone and/or fountain that spits water back into the pond you should have enough. A good rule of thumb is to add this increased aeration and just leave it running at all times.

Add Plants – Fish love the tender roots of plants such as Water Hyacinths and love to punch holes in the lily pads. Though they eat them and it can be tough to have both fish and plants, plants are naturally beneficial to your fish pond and you should not go without. Consider a separate section to your pond that the fish cannot swim to, perhaps an upper pond where the water circulates through before going back to the main pond area.

Filtration – We could go on for days about the proper filtration. We will only touch on the reasons for filtration in this article. Here are a few reasons to filter your water: (1) Remove Large "Trash" in the Water – Leaves and mulm will not go through filtration material and will be removed when you clean the filter media. (2) Remove Ammonia - Fish give off waste which is ammonia in the pond water and lethal in any concentration. Nature provides good bacteria that breaks ammonia down to something harmless and useful. This bacteria needs a place to grow and that’s what a biological filter will provide. (3) Prevent Algae Growth – Again, algae is a natural pond inhabitant. Plants compete with algae for nuitrients present in the water. One way to check the growth of algae is to provide vegetable filtration (plenty of plants). The less nutrition in the soil you use for the plants, the better. Pond water has all the nutrients the plants need and any fertilization efforts feed algae as well.

As you can see there is indeed a difference in how you build your pond if you want to keep fish. This is in no way a scare tactic to keep you away from fish. We have hundreds and we find complete enjoyment not only in our beautiful water gardens but in our fish as well. We feel they are worth the extra effort.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Whatsapp Pocket


No comments

Related Posts:

There’s basically 3 types of ornamental ponds — The Water Garden, The Goldfish Pond and The Koi Pond. The Water Garden which has only water and plants (and maybe a frog or two) is low-maintenance and intended to accent the beauty of the plantings only. The Goldfish Pond, also relatively low-maintenance, needs aeration, water, plants and a small filtration system. The Koi Pond requires excellent water quality. The need for adequate and external filtration is a must.
It sounds as if we’re always pushing large ponds that cater to the health of fish. This may be true. We simply adore the little babies. Some folks, however, prefer a smaller or less complicated pond system or a simple water feature in the garden. They want a spot in the garden that hardly ever needs tending where they can sit and relax without having to worry about biological filtration that converts ammonia to nitrites, etc. for the sake of the fish in the pond. We know just the thing for these folks. A small waterfall, a pleasant pool filled with natural greenery or an elegant fountain hidden in the garden’s secret room are all ways to enhance the garden with water features without all the work. If an occasional frog inhabits the pond, well, that’s okay too.
Definite noticeable changes occur in koi and goldfish, plants and the pond itself as the temperature of the water begins to drop. Leaves on water plants start to brown and die back. Koi and goldfish become less active and require less food. Leaves fall and cover the surface of the pond. The pond may suddenly clear up after not being clear all year. These are changes we see. The changes we do not see are just as important.
Certain biological processes must occur before a pond is fully seeded and balanced. Nitrifying bacteria must be present and working in the pond’s ecosystem before the pond can promote a healthy environment for aquatic life. New ponds will have none of those necessary biological processes in place. This creates a “New Pond Syndrome” that can be frustrating if the new pond owner is not equipped with knowledge on how to deal with it. Giving the pond time to develop these processes is the most important step and there are things that we can do to hasten the development.
You may not want to hear this — but it’s time to get off your duff and stop procrastinating. There is no better time than NOW to complete or start that pond project that you’ve been putting off. At this time of year pond waters are cooling, the weather’s not too hot and you stand a better chance at booking a more qualified pond builder. The cooler waters of autumn and winter hold dissolved oxygen better than warm water. This makes it less stressful to house koi and goldfish in smaller tanks while their home is being refurbished. Fish stop eating as much and as often, requiring less filtration, thus causing less load on temporary filters.
Springtime is the most critical time of the year for fish in the pond. As water temperatures rise it puts our fish in the danger zone also referred to as Aeromonas Alley. The danger zone is water temperatures between 50° and 65°. In many states during the winter the water temperature drops below 50° which kills all the bacteria (good and bad) and most parasites become inactive. Fish do not eat at these temperatures and the pond goes into a period of dormancy. Here in Georgia, however, spring's warmer daytime temperatures starts raising the water temperature but we still have cool nights.